Member store of the Premier Group member store

Member of the Premier Group

Shop online and get FREE curbside pickup, with the same great prices as in store!

Toggle Nav

Prestige Wine & Spirits
3410 Amelia Drive, Orchard Park, NY 14127
Call Us: 716-825-9848

  • Sign In
  • Create an Account
My Cart
Menu
Account

FREE curbside pickup on any order!

Curbside and In-Store Pickup Orders

Get FREE curbside pickup on any order! Orders are typically taking 1-2 business hours to complete at this time. Please wait for an email confirming that your order is ready before coming to the store.

The Dollar Sale is on now!

The Dollar Sale at Premier: Double Up for a Buck on over 100 select wines!

The Dollar Sale is on now at Premier! For a limited time and on select wines, when you buy one bottle at regular price, get a second identical bottle for just ONE DOLLAR! DOUBLE UP FOR A BUCK!

FREE Shipping to New York State on orders over $200!

Special Offer: Get FREE Shipping within New York State on orders over $200!

Now you can get FREE ground shipping to destinations within New York state on orders over $200! There's no coupon code necessary! This applies to 750ml bottles of wine only.

Shop By
Now Shopping by
  1. Spirit Subtype
    rye
Clear All
Shopping Options
Package Size
  1. 750 ml. 71items
  2. 1.75 L. 1item
  3. 1.0 L. 4items
  4. 375 ml. 3items
Vintage
  1. Batch:1 1item
  2. NV 78items
Price
-
Spirit Subtype
  1. American blended 21items
  2. bourbon 305items
  3. moonshine 30items
  4. rye 79items
Country
  1. United States 78items
  2. Canada 1item
Region
  1. Kentucky 6items
Rating Source
  1. Wine Enthusiast 23items
Rating
Awards and Accolades
  1. Premier Select 5items
Spec. Designation
  1. Kosher 2items
Compare Products
  1. Remove This Item
Compare
Clear All
You have no items to compare.
My Wish List
Last Added Items
  1. Add to Cart
    Remove This Item
Go to Wish List
You have no items in your wish list.

American

Shop Top American Whiskies at WineMadeEasy.com

Shop Top American Whiskies at WineMadeEasy.com

In America, we've taken an import from Europe -- whiskey -- and made it completely our own. Our Bourbon and Tennessee Whiskeys are as American as apple pie, and the blossoming scene of craft whiskey distilleries continue to push American whiskey to new levels of innovation and flavor. Shop all of the top American Whiskies right here at WineMadeEasy.com!

View as Grid List

Items 1-15 of 79

Set Ascending Direction
Page
per page
Shop By
Clear All
Shopping Options
Package Size
  1. 750 ml. 71items
  2. 1.75 L. 1item
  3. 1.0 L. 4items
  4. 375 ml. 3items
Vintage
  1. Batch:1 1item
  2. NV 78items
  1. New Riff Single Barrel Rye
    New Riff Single Barrel Rye

    Barrel Proof Without Chill Filtration
    NV / 750 ml. | Item#60694

    Premier SelectPremier Select wines are handpicked by our staff from amongst thousands of wines for their exceptional quality. They're made by a top producer and comparable to wines at twice the cost.
    Product Location

    United States

    Spirit Type

    American Whiskey

    This item cannot be shipped. It's available for local delivery and in-store pickup only

    Not Shippable. Western New York Local Delivery and In-Store Pickup only. Learn More Sorry, this item is not available for shipment outside of the Western New York area. Due to state liquor laws, we're unable to ship spirits (with the exception of local delivery options near our store location). We regret this inconvenience.

    Compare at $64.99 $59.99

    You save: $5.00 (8%)

    Add to Wish List Add to Compare
  2. Quarter Horse Kentucky Rye Whiskey
    Quarter Horse Kentucky Rye Whiskey

    NV / 750 ml. | Item#50213

    Premier SelectPremier Select wines are handpicked by our staff from amongst thousands of wines for their exceptional quality. They're made by a top producer and comparable to wines at twice the cost.
    Product Location

    United States | Kentucky

    Spirit Type

    American Whiskey

    This item cannot be shipped. It's available for local delivery and in-store pickup only

    Not Shippable. Western New York Local Delivery and In-Store Pickup only. Learn More Sorry, this item is not available for shipment outside of the Western New York area. Due to state liquor laws, we're unable to ship spirits (with the exception of local delivery options near our store location). We regret this inconvenience.

    Compare at $29.99 $24.99

    You save: $5.00 (17%)

    Add to Wish List Add to Compare
  3. Sazerac Rye
    Sazerac Rye

    Premier Single Barrel Selection
    NV / 750 ml. | Item#58574

    WE9393 pts. - Wine Enthusiast - 7/1/2016
    The aroma entices with bold caramel and vanilla. The palate is brisk and relatively dry, despite the succulent aroma, showing vanilla and oak up front, and rounding into nutmeg, almond, vanilla and bitter orange on the finish. Versatile for cocktails, including its namesake Sazerac.     WHA8888 pts. - Whisky Advocate - Winter, 2005
    Youthful and very lively. Bold, crisp, spices (mint, cinnamon, vanilla) are softened by soothing, sweeter notes (candied fruit, coconut, caramel, and rum notes), becoming dry, flinty, and spicy on the finish. It is very clean and polished, and it is superior to other rye whiskeys in this age range. Nicely done!
    Premier SelectPremier Select wines are handpicked by our staff from amongst thousands of wines for their exceptional quality. They're made by a top producer and comparable to wines at twice the cost.
    Product Location

    United States

    Spirit Type

    American Whiskey

    This item cannot be shipped. It's available for local delivery and in-store pickup only

    Not Shippable. Western New York Local Delivery and In-Store Pickup only. Learn More Sorry, this item is not available for shipment outside of the Western New York area. Due to state liquor laws, we're unable to ship spirits (with the exception of local delivery options near our store location). We regret this inconvenience.

    Limited Inventory

    2 items or less in stock. We will confirm your order by email.

    Compare at $34.99 $29.99

    You save: $5.00 (14%)

    Add to Wish List Add to Compare
  4. WhistlePig Old World Rye Bespoke Blend
    WhistlePig Old World Rye Bespoke Blend

    Aged 12 Years
    NV / 750 ml. | Item#55768

    Premier SelectPremier Select wines are handpicked by our staff from amongst thousands of wines for their exceptional quality. They're made by a top producer and comparable to wines at twice the cost.
    Product Location

    Canada

    Spirit Type

    American Whiskey

    This item cannot be shipped. It's available for local delivery and in-store pickup only

    Not Shippable. Western New York Local Delivery and In-Store Pickup only. Learn More Sorry, this item is not available for shipment outside of the Western New York area. Due to state liquor laws, we're unable to ship spirits (with the exception of local delivery options near our store location). We regret this inconvenience.

    Compare at $159.00 $129.00

    You save: $30.00 (19%)

    Add to Wish List Add to Compare
  5. Rittenhouse Straight Rye Whiskey
    Rittenhouse Straight Rye Whiskey

    Bottled-In-Bond
    NV / 750 ml. | Item#27288

    WE9595 pts. - Wine Enthusiast - 7/1/2016
    A versatile must-have for mixing cocktails, look for pleasing vanilla, maple and a hint of dried cherry. The finish is long and drying, with plenty of baking spice notes.
    Product Location

    United States

    Spirit Type

    American Whiskey

    This item cannot be shipped. It's available for local delivery and in-store pickup only

    Not Shippable. Western New York Local Delivery and In-Store Pickup only. Learn More Sorry, this item is not available for shipment outside of the Western New York area. Due to state liquor laws, we're unable to ship spirits (with the exception of local delivery options near our store location). We regret this inconvenience.

    Limited Inventory

    4 items or less in stock. We will confirm your order by email.

    $25.99

    Best Buy

    Add to Wish List Add to Compare
  6. Old Overholt Straight Rye Whiskey
    Old Overholt Straight Rye Whiskey

    Aged 4 Years
    NV / 1.0 L. | Item#60033

    WHA8686 pts. - Whisky Advocate - Spring, 2019
    A veteran rye whiskey brand that flaunts the floral quality of younger ryes with its summer flowers, bright citrus, and lemon oil notes. A well-polished palate, with warm porridge, and grain notes that smack of peanut butter on warm toast. Nice character and balance, if a touch anemic at this proof.     WE85+85–89 pts. - Wine Enthusiast - 6/7/2006
    The first sniffings detect notes of black pepper and oak resin; aeration adds stone-dry scents to minerals, slate, and sage. The palate entry is lean, semisweet, intensely grainy, and satisfying; at midpalate the whiskey lies well on the tongue, sweet, grainy, medium plump, and spicy. A very solid rye whiskey that deserves a larger audience.
    Product Location

    United States

    Spirit Type

    American Whiskey

    This item cannot be shipped. It's available for local delivery and in-store pickup only

    Not Shippable. Western New York Local Delivery and In-Store Pickup only. Learn More Sorry, this item is not available for shipment outside of the Western New York area. Due to state liquor laws, we're unable to ship spirits (with the exception of local delivery options near our store location). We regret this inconvenience.

    $23.99

    Best Buy

    Add to Wish List Add to Compare
  7. Angel’s Envy Finished Rye
    Angel’s Envy Finished Rye

    Rye Whiskey Finished in Caribbean Rum Casks
    NV / 750 ml. | Item#40026

    WHA9090 pts. - Whisky Advocate - Summer, 2013
    The folks at Angel’s Envy once again push the envelope with this 95% rye whiskey finished in Caribbean rum casks. Vibrant, spicy rye notes (cinnamon and mint) are tamed by rich maple syrup, graham cracker crust, nutty toffee, candy floss, subtle tropical fruit, and creamy vanilla. Warm, spicy, rummy finish. This is a mood whiskey — not one I would drink every day — but the flavors marry nicely and the sweetness tames this high-testosterone rye whiskey. Bonus points for uniqueness.
    Product Location

    United States

    Spirit Type

    American Whiskey

    This item cannot be shipped. It's available for local delivery and in-store pickup only

    Not Shippable. Western New York Local Delivery and In-Store Pickup only. Learn More Sorry, this item is not available for shipment outside of the Western New York area. Due to state liquor laws, we're unable to ship spirits (with the exception of local delivery options near our store location). We regret this inconvenience.

    Limited Inventory

    5 items or less in stock. We will confirm your order by email.

    Compare at $99.99 $89.99

    You save: $10.00 (10%)

    Add to Wish List Add to Compare
  8. High West Whiskey Rendezvous Rye
    High West Whiskey Rendezvous Rye

    NV / 750 ml. | Item#28776

    WE9696 pts. - Wine Enthusiast - 11/1/2010
    Strong but intriguing. Medium color and body, with rich aromas of burnt orange and caramel. The flavor also reflected burnt orange and caramel, plus a spicy tinge reminiscent of cassia bark or Red-Hot candies. The finish lingers, pleasant, inviting and warm. Might be good for Manhattans — a touch of fruit or sweetness would go well with this rye. Excellent value.     WHA9595 pts. - Whisky Advocate - Winter, 2008
    A blend of two whiskeys; a 6 year old made from 95% rye and a 16 year old made from 80% rye. These are very high percentages; a straight rye whiskey only needs to contain 51% rye to meet the definition. It was very clever to marry the vibrancy of a younger whiskey with the depth of a mature whiskey. Thanks to the high rye content, this whiskey is very spicy, with cinnamon, crisp mint, and fennel. Underlying sweet notes of caramel, molasses, vanilla, macaroon, cocoa, and candied fruit provide a calming effect and enhance the whiskey’s complexity. But in the end, the rye is the victor, emerging with a vengeance and giving the whisky a bold, warming, spice finish.
    Product Location

    United States

    Spirit Type

    American Whiskey

    This item cannot be shipped. It's available for local delivery and in-store pickup only

    Not Shippable. Western New York Local Delivery and In-Store Pickup only. Learn More Sorry, this item is not available for shipment outside of the Western New York area. Due to state liquor laws, we're unable to ship spirits (with the exception of local delivery options near our store location). We regret this inconvenience.

    Limited Inventory

    7 items or less in stock. We will confirm your order by email.

    $79.99

    Best Buy

    Add to Wish List Add to Compare
  9. John Myer Rye Whiskey
    John Myer Rye Whiskey

    NV / 750 ml. | Item#41597

    Product Location

    United States

    Spirit Type

    American Whiskey

    This item cannot be shipped. It's available for local delivery and in-store pickup only

    Not Shippable. Western New York Local Delivery and In-Store Pickup only. Learn More Sorry, this item is not available for shipment outside of the Western New York area. Due to state liquor laws, we're unable to ship spirits (with the exception of local delivery options near our store location). We regret this inconvenience.

    $44.99

    Best Buy

    Add to Wish List Add to Compare
  10. Knob Creek Straight Rye Whiskey
    Knob Creek Straight Rye Whiskey

    NV / 750 ml. | Item#34480

    WE9292 pts. - Wine Enthusiast - 9/1/2013
    Though this new offering meets the technical criteria for rye (a mash bill of at least 51% rye), the sweet, caramelly flavors suggest a high-rye Bourbon — which makes sense considering that Knob Creek is best known for its Bourbon. Expect bold almond, oak, brown butter and pecan pie flavors. The drying baking-spice finish is more characteristic of rye, and has less bite than might be expected of a 100-proof spirit.     WHA8585 pts. - Whisky Advocate - Summer, 2012
    Unlike the Knob Creek bourbons (which are 9 years old), there’s no age statement with this new rye, which tastes relatively younger. It’s bracing, vibrant, and spicy. (The rye contribution is unmistakable.) Cinnamon spice and crisp mint dominate, with charcoal, botanicals, ginger, nutmeg, honeyed fruit, vanilla, and caramel. Warming spice finish. Its dynamic personality should shine in cocktails, but from a sipping, drinking neat perspective, I wish it was a little older like its siblings.
    Product Location

    United States

    Spirit Type

    American Whiskey

    This item cannot be shipped. It's available for local delivery and in-store pickup only

    Not Shippable. Western New York Local Delivery and In-Store Pickup only. Learn More Sorry, this item is not available for shipment outside of the Western New York area. Due to state liquor laws, we're unable to ship spirits (with the exception of local delivery options near our store location). We regret this inconvenience.

    $39.99

    Best Buy

    Add to Wish List Add to Compare
  11. Old Overholt Bonded Straight Rye Whiskey
    Old Overholt Bonded Straight Rye Whiskey

    NV / 1.0 L. | Item#47831

    Product Location

    United States

    Spirit Type

    American Whiskey

    This item cannot be shipped. It's available for local delivery and in-store pickup only

    Not Shippable. Western New York Local Delivery and In-Store Pickup only. Learn More Sorry, this item is not available for shipment outside of the Western New York area. Due to state liquor laws, we're unable to ship spirits (with the exception of local delivery options near our store location). We regret this inconvenience.

    Limited Inventory

    7 items or less in stock. We will confirm your order by email.

    $31.99

    Best Buy

    Add to Wish List Add to Compare
  12. Basil Hayden’s Dark Rye
    Basil Hayden’s Dark Rye

    Kentucky Straight Rye Whiskey blended with Canadian Rye Whisky and Port
    NV / 750 ml. | Item#46258

    Product Location

    United States

    Spirit Type

    American Whiskey

    This item cannot be shipped. It's available for local delivery and in-store pickup only

    Not Shippable. Western New York Local Delivery and In-Store Pickup only. Learn More Sorry, this item is not available for shipment outside of the Western New York area. Due to state liquor laws, we're unable to ship spirits (with the exception of local delivery options near our store location). We regret this inconvenience.

    Limited Inventory

    8 items or less in stock. We will confirm your order by email.

    $44.99

    Best Buy

    Add to Wish List Add to Compare
  13. Black Dirt Rye
    Black Dirt Rye

    Batch No. 002
    NV / 750 ml. | Item#49399

    Product Location

    United States

    Spirit Type

    American Whiskey

    This item cannot be shipped. It's available for local delivery and in-store pickup only

    Not Shippable. Western New York Local Delivery and In-Store Pickup only. Learn More Sorry, this item is not available for shipment outside of the Western New York area. Due to state liquor laws, we're unable to ship spirits (with the exception of local delivery options near our store location). We regret this inconvenience.

    Limited Inventory

    5 items or less in stock. We will confirm your order by email.

    $44.99

    Best Buy

    Add to Wish List Add to Compare
  14. Bradshaw Kentucky Straight Rye Whiskey
    Bradshaw Kentucky Straight Rye Whiskey

    NV / 750 ml. | Item#56785

    Product Location

    United States

    Spirit Type

    American Whiskey

    This item cannot be shipped. It's available for local delivery and in-store pickup only

    Not Shippable. Western New York Local Delivery and In-Store Pickup only. Learn More Sorry, this item is not available for shipment outside of the Western New York area. Due to state liquor laws, we're unable to ship spirits (with the exception of local delivery options near our store location). We regret this inconvenience.

    Limited Inventory

    11 items or less in stock. We will confirm your order by email.

    $44.99

    Best Buy

    Add to Wish List Add to Compare
  15. Bulleit 95 Rye
    Bulleit 95 Rye

    NV / 1.0 L. | Item#41739

    WE9191 pts. - Wine Enthusiast - 7/1/2013
    Bright and buttery, this rye has a warm, malty scent and mellow flavors of cookie dough and juicy lemon, interspersed with just the right amount of rye bite.     WHA8585 pts. - Whisky Advocate - Summer, 2011
    No age statement, but it includes 4 to 7 year old whiskeys. The mashbill is 95% rye — much higher than most standard rye whiskeys out there. It’s brisk, vibrant, and loaded with spice (crisp mint, warming cinnamon, cocoa, hint of anise). Fruit — ripe nectarine, apricot, golden raisin — drizzled with maple syrup. Dry oak rounds out the finish. Bold enough for cocktails. Mature enough to drink neat (or on the rocks).
    Product Location

    United States

    Spirit Type

    American Whiskey

    This item cannot be shipped. It's available for local delivery and in-store pickup only

    Not Shippable. Western New York Local Delivery and In-Store Pickup only. Learn More Sorry, this item is not available for shipment outside of the Western New York area. Due to state liquor laws, we're unable to ship spirits (with the exception of local delivery options near our store location). We regret this inconvenience.

    $42.99

    Best Buy

    Add to Wish List Add to Compare
Page
per page